top of page
Naperville & NOW OPEN in Batavia!
Hours | Tues - Sun | 11am - 8pm
We are closed on Mondays
Place Online Order Here or call ahead for pick-up Naperville: 630-544-6626 Batavia: 331-334-8109
We understand there is a wide selection of carefully crafted grilled cheese sandwiches for you to enjoy. We don't put a limit on how many times you can return for more. In fact, we even have a club for our most loyal customers!
Hand-Crafted Grilled Cheese
Renegade Gourmet inspired sandwiches.
Flavor with flare. Dignified, yet never pretentious. Always delicious!All American
A perfectly toasted American grilled cheese on texas toast
$6.99
Vegetarian
Usual Suspect
crispy bacon, tomato, american, swiss, and havarti on texas toast
$10.25
Mostly Maui Wowie
Boar's Head ham, grilled pineapple, and havarti on texas toast. Served with a side of homemade rim sauce
$10.75
Buffalo Chicken
grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, havarti, and bleu cheese crumbles on texas toast
$10.75
Tuna Turner
tuna salad, shredded lettuce, tomato, and cheddar on wheat
$10.75
'81 Caprice Classic
tomato, basil, arugula, balsamic glaze, and mozzarella on wheat
$9.75
Vegetarian
Spicy Smokey Cheesy Bacon
crispy bacon, jalapeƱos, smoked gouda, and cheddar on texas toast
$10.25
Turkey Meltdown
Boar's Head turkey, crispy bacon, tomato, swiss, and cheddar topped with chipotle mayo on texas toast
$10.75
Homemade Sloppy Joan
ground beef in homemade sloppy sauce, american, and cheddar on texas toast
$10.25
Eddie Mack & Cheese
macaroni & cheese disguised as grilled cheese on texas toast
$9.25
Vegetarian
Sloppy Mack
Homemade Sloppy Joan combined with Eddie Mack & Cheese with american cheese on texas toast
$9.75
Al Pa-Cheeso
capicola, salami, Boar's Head ham, Freddie's giardiniera, and provolone on texas toast
$10.75
The Reuben
corned beef, sauerkraut, homemade russian dressing, and swiss on rye
$11.25
Horseradish Club
Boar's Head ham & turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and horseradish cheddar on texas toast
$11.25
Messy Jessie
thinly sliced Boar's Head London broil topped with homemade horseradish slaw, cheddar, and havarti on texas toast. Served with a side of Au Jus
$11.25
The Socra-Cheez
gyro meat, grilled onions, tomato, tzatziki sauce, havarti, and feta crumbles on texas toast
$10.75
Nakatomi
teriyaki chicken, grilled pineapple, grilled onions, cheddar, and havarti on texas toast
$10.75
BUILD YOUR OWN GRILLED CHEESE
Includes 2 cheeses on texas toast. Any additional cheeses or toppings will come as an extra charge.Cheese
american, swiss, havarti, cheddar, smoked gouda, provolone, mozzarella, pepperjack, horseradish cheddar, bleu cheese crumbles, feta crumbles
$1.75
Meats
crispy bacon, Boar's Head Turkey, Boar's Head Ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni, grilled chicken, gyro meat, corned beef, London broil,
$2.50
Veggies
tomato, onion (grilled or raw), grilled mushrooms, pineapple, giardiniera, basil, arugula, shredded lettuce, red pepper, dill pickles, jalapeƱos
$1.50
Avocado
$2.50
Other
Sloppy joe, mack & cheese, tuna salad, horseradish slaw
$2.99
Sauces
Add some extra flavor to your grilled cheese!
Homemade ranch, buffalo, teriyaki, mayo, chipotle mayo, ketchup, yellow mustard, dijon mustard
$0.75
1/2 GRILLED CHEESE & SOUP COMBO
The best of both worlds!1/2 Grilled Cheese & Soup Combo
A half grilled cheese of your choice with a
cup of soup
$10.50
1/2 All American Grilled Cheese & Soup Combo
A half All American grilled cheese with a cup of soup
$6.99
KIDS MEAL
Comes with half of an All American grilled cheese and your choice of side & drink!
$7.50Kids Meal Drink Options
Apple Juice, Coke product, milk, chocolate milk, or bottled water.Milk
Chocolate Milk
Apple Juice
Bottled Water
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Kids Meal Side Options
Dipper of tomato soup, chips, sliced apple, or yogurt. Dipper of Tomato Soup
Sliced Apple
Joe Chips
Yogurt
SALADS
Not feeling a grilled cheese? We have salads!Grilled Cheese House Salad
mixed field greens with homemade grilled cheese croutons, grape tomatoes, and bacon crumbles served with your choice of homemade ranch dressing, russian dressing, or rim sauce.
$9.99
Buffalo Chicken Salad
mixed field greens with diced grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, diced celery, grape tomatoes, and bleu cheese crumbles served with homemade ranch dressing.
$10.99
SOUPS & SIDES
Want a little extra? Check out our delicious homemade soups and sides!Homemade Tomato Soup
Homemade tomato soup made fresh each morning in house! The best dipper for the cheesiest of grilled cheeses! Dipper
$2.25
Cup
$4.50
Bowl
$7.75
Mack & Cheese
An 8oz cup or 16oz bowl of our delicious homemade Mack & Cheese!Cup
$4.99
Bowl
$7.99
Sloppy Mack
An 8oz cup or 16oz bowl of our homemade Mack & Cheese combined with Sloppy Joan. Cup
$5.25
Bowl
$8.99
Tommy Mack
Mack & cheese combined with our homemade tomato soup. Think gourmet spaghettios!Cup
$4.99
Bowl
$7.99
Community Chips
Complete your grilled cheese meal with a bag of chips!
$2.50
Flavor
Classic
BBQ
Sour Cream and Onion
Pickle
Whole, halved, or quartered! It's a delicious pickle, any way you slice it.
$1.99
Desserts
Ask us what we've got!Chocolate Chip Cookie
Sugar Cookie
My New Option
Krispies
Little Krispies
DRINKS
A cold beverage to wash down a warm grilled cheese!Drinks
Bottled water, Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Juice, Milk
$2.25
Craft Teas & Sodas
$3.25
Place Online Order Here or call ahead for pick-up Naperville: 630-544-6626 Batavia: 331-334-8109
bottom of page